A City upon A Hill reading reflection
Read John Winthrop’s “A Model of Christian Charity.” Puritan leader John Winthrop’s description of American as a “city upon a hill” contributed to the idea of American exceptionalism. The phrase has been recycled by several politicians, most notably John F. Kennedy and Ronald Reagan.
Click on the two blue links below to listen to the speeches from Kennedy and Reagan.
Pay careful attention to how they make use of the “city upon a hill” phrase.
Former President John F. Kennedy’s Speech (Click here to view Former President John F. Kennedy’s speech)
Former President Ronal Reagan’s Speech (Click here to view Former President Ronald Reagan’s speech)
In paragraph one, discuss how each speaker (Winthrop, Kennedy, and Reagan) interpreted the phrase “city upon a hill” and if Kennedy and Reagan interpretations are similar to or different from Winthrop’s interpretation? While creating your argument, consider when the phrase that were used. For example, Kennedy used the phrase when entering office, and Reagan used the phrase as a farewell when leaving office.
In paragraph two, discuss which parts of Winthrop’s advice do you think would be the most effective in building a strong community? Why? Be specific.
In paragraph three, share your thoughts on if you feel America still consider itself a model for the rest of the world? Why or why not? Make sure you provide specific evidence of current events to support your position, and be respectful.
Note: each paragraph should be at least 100-words and remember to indent and edit your paragraphs before submission.
