Ms. Farry Advanced Composition
A Lesson Before Dying: Essay Topics
For your summative on Ernest Gaines’s A Lesson Before Dying, choose one of the following topics:
Explore how Wiggins depicts the education system in the novel, examining how the scenes set within the classroom inform, contextualize or contrast with the learning that occurs beyond school walls.
Embark on a character study of Vivian. Why does Wiggins include this character in the novel? How does the strand of the story focused on Vivian’s relationship with Grant relate to the main storyline involving Grant’s interaction with Jefferson?
In what ways is Vivian similar to or different from the other female characters (Tante Lou, Miss Emma)?
“I saw the transformation,” the prison guard tells Grant near the end of the novel, declaring himself a witness to Jefferson’s extraordinary progression.
To what extent does Grant also undergo a transformation in the narrative? How does the teacher change, what does he learn, and in what ways might his transformation be incomplete?
Consider his perspective in the beginning, middle and end of the novel.
Explore the depiction of faith and religion in the novel.
Design your own topic based on a pattern, problem or question that intrigues you. If you choose this option, make sure to talk about your proposed topic.
Whatever option you choose, you must support your thinking with specific references to the text, including at least four direct quotations. Each quotation may be no more than 2-3 lines. If necessary, use ellipses (…) to highlight the essential phrases.
Due Sunday, November 7 (itsLearning dropbox): Write a prospectus for your paper, including:
The topic you have chosen.
What draws you to this topic: what aspects of this topic capture your curiosity and why?
Your initial questions/hunches about this topic
A provisional thesis that articulates a specific argument/theory/angle you want to put forward. The preliminary thesis is “provisional,” meaning that you may need to revise it as your reading, writing and thinking continues.
At least two specific quotations from the novel that you will be examining in the paper.
Due Monday, Nov. 10 (suggested due date if you want feedback before the final draft): Email Ms. Farry either a completed draft of the paper or a near-completed draft that includes all but a finished intro and conclusion.
Due Friday, Nov. 12: hand in final copy of essay to itsLearning dropbox
Suggested length: 3-4 pages (doublespaced, standard font)
Some hints for a successful paper…
Provide a catchy and relevant title.
Include an introduction that ends in a thesis statement, which sets up the problem your essay will investigate and the particular angle of exploration that your essay will pursue. Ex:
Within the schoolroom, Grant follows rules and imposes discipline; in teaching Jefferson, however, he comes to defy authority and demonstrate compassion.
Other ideas for the introduction: you might begin with a catchy (but relevant) opening; you might define some of the key terms in your thesis statement; you might set up the stakes for your essay (what drew you to this particular problem / why you think it is worthy of investigation).
Include several body paragraphs with at least one quotation (perhaps two) from the book in each. Begin each body paragraph by introducing the particular dimension of the argument/inquiry that you will focus on in this section of the essay (more specific than the thesis statement). Do not begin or end a paragraph with plot summary.
Include a minimum of four quotations from the book in your essay. Set up each quotation by providing some brief context (who, what, when, where, why). Ex: On Grant’s second visit, Jefferson remains dehumanized and hopeless:
“And his eyes were just blank—blank, blank, my aunt said. He could have been looking at the wall or the floor, for all the recognition he showed her” (33).
Cite all quotations parenthetically, following MLA standards. See above. Each quotation may be no more than 2-3 lines. If necessary, use ellipses (…) to highlight the essential phrases.
The heart of the paper is analysis – that is, your thoughtful exploration of the text. Respond to the quotations from the book that you’ve selected:
What might they mean? What do they reveal? What questions do they raise?
How do they help to shed light on the problem that you are focusing on in this essay?
How do they support your theories or complicate your assumptions? Pay attention to language and structure—for example, the effect of a particular word or phrase.
Acknowledge multiple possibilities and alternative points of view—for example, respond to an opposing argument or present more than one way of looking at a particular passage.
Avoid plot summary.
Provide a conclusion in which you consider overarching insights that have emerged in the writing of the paper as well as any new or lingering questions.
Use active verbs, and use the “literary present” tense.
