Week 3: Implicatures
Each of the following single statements has at least one implicature in the situation described. What is it?
Statement: You make a better door than a window.
Situation: Someone is blocking your view.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Statement: It’s getting late.
Situation: You’re at a party and it’s 4 A.M.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Statement: The restaurants are open until midnight.
Situation: It’s 10 o’clock and you haven’t eaten dinner.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Statement: I thought I saw a fan in the closet.
Situation: It’s sweltering in the room.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Statement: If you’d diet, this wouldn’t hurt so badly.
Situation: Someone is standing on your toe.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Statement: Mr. Smith dresses neatly, is well groomed, and is always on time to class.
Situation: The summary statement in a letter of recommendation to graduate school.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Describe the entailment relationships (A entails B, B entails A, synonymous, contradictory) between the following groups of sentences.
1. A) My mom lives in Toronto.
B) My mom lives in Canada
2. A) Josh kissed Emily.
B) Emily was kissed by Josh.
3. A) Tony goes to school every day.
B) Tony didn’t go to school last week.
4. A) Jack and Jill went up the hill.
B) Jack went up the hill.
C) Jack didn’t go up the hill
5. A) Nick plays sports
B) Nick plays baseball
C) Nick doesn’t play baseball
Suppose the reference (meaning) of loves points out the set consisting of the following pairs of individuals: <Anna, Paul>, <Paul, Benjamin>, <Benjamin, Benjamin>, <Paul, Anna>. Determine what is the meaning of the verb phrase (e.g., loves Anna the meaning of the VP loves Anna is the set of individuals consisting of Paul)
loves Paul
loves Benjamin
loves Jack
Given the information in (B), for which of the following sentences are the truth conditions produced by Semantic Rule I met?
Paul loves Anna.
Benjamin loves Paul.
Benjamin loves himself.
Anna loves Jack.
CHALLENGE QUESTION:
Consider the sentence Jack kissed Laura. How would the actions of Semantic Rules (I) and (II) determine that the sentence is false if it were true that:
Nobody kissed Laura.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
How about if it were true that: ii. Jack did not kiss Laura, although other men did.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
